Since 2005, Traveller’s Tales (TT) has produced 14 LEGO video games based on LEGO-licensed properties, including Star Wars, Indiana Jones, Batman/DC, Harry Potter, Pirates of the Caribbean, Marvel, and Lord of the Rings/Hobbit titles. These games all follow a similar gameplay style, structured around destroying and rebuilding LEGO environments, collecting LEGO studs, and unlocking hidden characters. The narratives of the games are humorous takes on the franchises on which they are based, and players are invited to relive these films and characters through the lens of LEGO nostalgia and wit.
The question I want to explore here is why, given the games’ extraordinarily repetitive gameplay and design structure, do I (and many others) find these games so appealing?
For me, the pleasure derives both from the comforts of repetition as well as the nostalgic aspects of engagement with the franchises. The joy of LEGO bricks, in part, comes from the process of creation, destruction, and rebuilding. The video games are built on a similar logic, sharing the same core activity of building and destruction. They are also strongly interactive and focused on puzzle completion and obsessive collecting. And like the different sets of LEGO bricks, the games offer a variety of LEGO worlds to inhabit. I liken playing the games to following the instructions in a LEGO set. As with a set of building instructions, the games are generally quite linear (though they do require multiple playthroughs to complete all of the puzzles). Like the games, the basic “gameplay” of the bricks doesn’t change: one simply assembles bricks in different orders. The pleasure comes from the process of this repetitive activity, from seeing how a different arrangement of parts can produce a new whole.
The games also allow a Gen-X/Millennial player like me to re-experience movies and characters from my youth. Both LEGO and the films/characters the games reference are saturated with nostalgia, and the games produce an irresistible combination of these twin forces, all infused with LEGO’s brand of humor. The games also give me something that, for example, the Marvel cinematic universe is unable to provide. Free from film studio licensing agreements, TT’s Marvel LEGO game can have Spider-Man team-up with the Hulk and Wolverine play nice with Iron Man—something currently impossible at the multiplex. If TT ever produces a Marvel/DC crossover game, it will have almost completely satisfied my fanboy dreams.