Curator's Note
“Sound qua sound,” writes Julian Henriques in his study of dub music.[1] His book is about dub, a communal, grinding, erotic music, but he begins in a call to study sound as sound. He does not want to produce a history and theory of dub that enters the metaphorical or analogous, where sound comes to stand in for something else, nor does he seek just a historical, contextual narrative of music production. Henriques places his study as an interrogation of sound as sound, a living in and feeling out of what sound is and what it does. The work of sound, the feeling of sound, the effect of sound becomes the form we call music. Music as an effect, not the work. Henriques tasks us to “think through sound,” and distinguishes this from our “habitual thinking through images” and even against a thinking through music. Sound qua sound, he tells us, is a not a thinking “about,” an accumulative propagation of knowledge, but a process, “a way of thinking.”[2] He names it a gnosis and a techné—a spiritual and practiced knowledge. A mechanical process that feels out the material sound wave, the thing that hits the body, moves through the body, is reshaped by the body, and is shared with other bodies.
This provocation by Henriques is a difficult one for scholarship in the visual arts. He is right, those in visual disciplines have been habituated to think through images, and even when sound flows alongside the image, the image takes precedent. Film sound studies marks, if I may be slightly reductive, the representational relationship sound has to the image, how it syncs or is discordant with the image. Bastardizing José Esteban Muñoz, sound has been placed in either an identificatory or counter-identificatory relationship—an affirmative participation or an antagonistic disruption—but always in relation towards the normative center of film: the image of this visual medium.[3]
Music has its own burden of the visual. What is visual notation, be it the linear bars of western musical training or the “wheel method” that visualizes rhythm in the round, but the image and its representational desires solidifying sound into a repeatable and reusable music? Music’s movement into a soundfulness—those moments of vibratory ecstasy where the flowing, penetrating waves of sound propel the body—happen not through the musical notation, but in the gaps of that visual representation. Take Thomas Dorsey, the pioneering gospel composer who spread gospel music in the 20th century in part through his notational practice. As Maurice Wallace tells us, Dorsey’s notations were “only sketches,” more “generic than mimetic;” that is, “not scores for imitative or tightly fixed forms of vocal intonation or instrumental play.” [4] Horace Boyer described them as “open…spaces” that prioritize the improvisational over rigid reproducibility.[5] The revelatory quality of Dorsey’s gospel music arrives in the representational gaps not in the visible instructions. Here, sound without image is the site of sonic ecstasy.
I dwell here to point to the difficulty of leaving the visual in the study of sound because sound, unlike the image, is expansive and expanding; it is hard to study that which never stops moving. Fixing sound to the image makes that sound study-able, usable, deployable, reproducible. Sound in service of the image is a containment, a containment in utility. The sound that lands in and for the image makes sound useful to the image, a utilitarian conscription of sound to amplify, contextualize, mobilize, solidify, and reify the visual. The task I am attempting to name here for myself and my own limitations as a trained image scholar, is: what is an image studies bound in and for sound? What is a sound studies that is amplified and opened through the image, where the image and its solidity counterintuitively gives greater access to the work, the labor, and the potentialities of sound? Borrowing once more from Muñoz, a disidentifcatory use of the image so that sound may move as it pleases? Can we imagine sound through an image that then expands sound? Sound as a center, guide, impetus and impulse of the image? To borrow from Fred Moten, what if in the beginning of image studies there was sound and all that flows otherwise comes from that beginning?
liquid blackness found immense potentiality in suspension.[6] To suspend is a duality: to suspend in a chemical solution, to retain and hold in place; but also, to suspend in air, to fly, to hold up, to carry, to care. Is there a way that the image can be not a suspension in formaldehyde but a suspension in loving arms? A method where sound can relax, where sound can flow in new ways? The image as a medium for movement? Sound vibrates through things, and in so doing, changes its own vibrational resonance, and the vibrational resonances of all that it moves through. [7]
Can we imagine a visual studies that is ontologically a sound studies?
[1] Julian Henriques, Sonic Bodies: Reggae, Soundsystems, Performance Techniques, and Ways of Knowing, Bloomsbury Publishing, 2011: xvii.
[2] Ibid.
[3] José Esteban Muñoz. Disidentification: Queers of Color and the Performance of Politics, Minnesota University Press, 1999: 11.
[4] Maurice Wallace, King’s Vibrato: Modernism, Blackness, and the Sonic Life of Martin Luther King, Jr., Duke University Press, 2022: 102.
[5] Ibid.
[6] Muñoz, 12.
[7] Our method of study follows from the artists we study. Their sonic vision becoming our
“phono-optic” study, to borrow from Alexander Weheliye. These questions specifically follow from our deep engagement with Arthur Jafa and his “Black Visual Intonation,” where the image holds the emotional cadence of jazz and the black voice.
Add new comment